Відео

WOW !!! You really have the gift , incredible voice , you sing very proud .

all time favorite

Beauty song, beauty performer....

THIS IS GOLD!!!!

SAINT AUSTRALIA

Haunting yet soulful and beautiful rendition. You can feel it surrounding your body. A++++++++

Ffs, shut up about the Grateful Dead version!

I will always regret not going to this concert when i had the chance. Its still my favorite live version of this song . No matter how many times I've seen them live .

An old Scottish folk song

Is this song about a girl who saved her city and all of its people by manipulating the captain? There are many versions that evoke different possibilities.

Never heard of 'em.

Thinking of a lovely friend who passed this week. Fly high Catherine, you were one of the nicest that I had the pleasure of having met. An extraordinary woman that was called way to early.

so beautiful :)

We could only wish every bowel movement was a smooth and clean as his voice!!!

For a supposedly "rebellious" band they're pretty compliant with their masks & the vaccine mandates that they enforced at their shows back then. Hypocrisy.

Tlazcomati ✊🏽🪶 Thank you for this medicine. You're a special gift from Creator love you my liddo relative. JUCHARI UINAPIKUA ✊🏽 OUR STRENGTH/ POWER . #WESTILLHERE #PROUDLYINDIGENOUS #BROKENTREATIES #LANDBACK

Oh yeah. Thats the one.

This is dope by all measure, that guitar solo notwithstanding. But what I really like, is when your man walks off after laying the vocal down for the first measured bit of the song there, then he quenches his thirst. I feel it was a still well-iced drink. I felt those ice cubes hit my own teeth. It was watery; the drink was watered down. It was likely whiskey and water. Or a watery whiskey. I want that it was.

this is an auld scots sang(bonnie lass o fyvie'o) that bob dylan adapted in the early 60s. he also adapted another scots sang......farewell to tarwathie to farewell angelina. he also adapted another scots sang.....the road and the miles to dundee to the walls of redwing. he also adapted another 4 scots sangs.

I love ❤it so much...

My dad introduced me to The National at a young age and we grew up listening to them together. I've for some reason always known since the first time I heard this cover that I want it to be my father-daughter dance with him at my wedding. Can't wait for that moment.

Fabolous tume. Familiar and generous touch to s very old dong

Saw the Dead do this in Vegas in the 94 I think.

So restrained, just waiting to explode, I really wanted this rendition to crescendo but it doesn’t, just trails off in sadness.

We are all thrust into this Culture War BS. The elites divide us on purpose for their gain.. Call out Klaus and his puppets.. Macron, Trudeau, English PM, Jabcinda, Freeland... they ALL must go

What a song

Do The National know this song from Grateful Dead something else the same way as I know this song or is it a coincidence?

GrATEFUL DEAD played this song the greatest. Nobody comes close. Jerry owns this song

He said you may know as something else. Why don’t you give them credit. It was the Grateful Dead who made this song special. Garcia was magical on this song. If you haven’t heard, please check out Grateful Dead Peggy o. Their version was absolutely the greatest.

He sang this song like he was possessed by the soul of a brokenhearted ghost 10/10 no one else should cover this again.

🤍

There’s something “Joshua Tree’esque” about this version that jumps out at me. Love it

What a sound. Its the whole package. Haunting, deliberate, complex and totally unique. The National has to be the best band out of Cincy EVER!!!

Brazil 🎉😢 01/05/2023

What are the chords of the background melody? :D

Excellent version of a classic old folksong, often done by the Grateful Dead.

TYJ..nothing will ever compare to him. But nevertheless beautiful and haunting , great job guys!

I like the Dead's version better. This one just seems just a bit overwrought.

This song!!! Wow and what a PERFORMANCE!! I cannot listen to this once; I have to re-listen at least twice. Goosebumps every time. Man. APPLAUSE for the band!

I remember 50 years ago my older brother coming to our room singing this song. Twenty years later he was gone, affected by the consecuences of his addictions, but I never forget that sonic image that will be with me forever. Thanks for make me remember.

This is the worst political song of all time. Lmao, how boring and uninspired. 😂

Pretty amazing cover.

I’ve heard many versions and interpretations of this song and I’d have to say this band does a fantastic version. The vocals are clear for a live performance and the guitar work superb. Excellent upload.

Have been going deep on different versions of this song. From George and Gerry Armstrong to the Grateful Dead, this is one of the best

when bono met jerry. still.....whata powerful song.

I am just moved and blown away with tears streaming down my cheeks. The sound ,the emotions of this guy...I wasn't expecting this. i had forgotten about this Civil War Song( I've heard it was originally Scottish) until I recently watched a clip of Lead Guitarist G. E. Smith of Saturday Night Live House Band in the 70's talking about first meeting Bob Dylan. Then weirdly enough I came upon one of the The Grateful Dead Versions just 2 days ago and now THIS. I am 68 , played (piano) and have listened to many versions of many Songs from long ago to present. But NEVER something this Hauntingly beautiful. Thank you for transporting me back to The Civil War Days (or to Scotland), a true love lost , and s broken Heart best 7 mins and 12 seconds in quite a long time. An excellent surprise. Love this and will share with many Thanks for Posting this !

Timeless!

Him stopping to sing a song is a hilarious turn to the conversation

Sweet Dani O’, bff

What’s with the masks?