Відео

One thing that puts a hole in this theory with chapter 1136 is the fact that franks doesn't know where loki is. It stands to serve that Shanks would know exactly where loki is since he put him there in the first place.

To be fair, we know that bonney didnt eat the actual fruit so its entirely possible that rocks had the original age age fruit and saturn somehow acquired some of his blood or something during the god valley incident and used that on bonney, maybe the procedure used forced rocks to use distorted future/past whatever turning into dragon

Could be Dragon 🤔

If you remember in arlong park they showed how whirlpools were created by moving big pieces of land underwater and the water having to fill the gap creates the whirlpool. Because of this im not sure if its a devil fruit cause the sea would negate the power. Maybe he has another to do this. Technology or a fishman crew. Idk

I’ve always subscribed to the idea that Luffy is rocks grandson, via rocks being dragons father and him marrying garps daughter instead. She dies potentially in a Celestial dragon way, causing dragons get back arc. Your theory isn’t terrible but there are an extremely high level of what ifs that don’t make sense chronologically or thematically but you did do a solid job on the video

Gryphon and his rival Hawk eye. That would be kinda cool

The Rox pirated were at god valley for the rare devil fruits on the island

Honestly I'd rather Rocks stay a full 100% villain, it just does so much good for Luffy vs Blackbeard conflict. Two rivals of the past clashing in new bodies, two sides of absolute freedom meeting yet again

So....Dragon was Rocks who became Dragon after someone awakened the age fruit and met Crocodile who was a woman, had Luffy and then Crocodile became a man. So Luffy's mom is a man and his dad is also old enough to be his Grandpa but he took on Garp's name, (his peer and dad)...makes perfect sense.

I feel like the man marked by flames is referring to Luffy, since he was burned by Akainu during Marineford which quite literally marked him with flames and gave him his iconic X scar in the process.

You didn't have me until you pointed out how ivankov and kuma are 2 halves to what happened to rocks, now I think you may be onto something

OK, then how is Shanks' past related to Mihawk? What I know is that Shanks once told Mihawk the Luffy/Joyboy story

I like it

garp said in the manga that my son quit marine to become .. so your title doesn't make sense

There is no way that the celestial dragons respect Shanks even if Garling is his father. He lives with all of the rest of the lowlives and he is actively protecting them.

17:07 chapter 4 billion 😂

Nah this is too good

This is crazy good with everything going on now even shanks has a twin (potentially )

17:06 in WHAT chapter?!

it might be possible but characters in one piece look similar with similar wills. Like luffy looks like roger. So, it could be that dragon inherited rock's will

Rocks is caribou

It has just been confirmed that dragon is garps son

You can of worms opening theoretical genius

This is a very cool theory, and it goes well with KoL's latest theory too about Garling.

Gonna look like a 🤡🤡🤡 real soon

Timeline is all off

Luffy mirrors roger. Ace mirrors whitebeard. Sabo mirrors shanks. Sabo doesnt want to be a noble something something shanks and celestial dragons

I really like this theory! Especially the part about the man marked by flames having a ship Mark by flames. Keep up the good work bro

I dont think the ages add up 🤔

I really hope this shanks theory isn't true. Being the leader of the God knights pretty much ruins his character for me . But I guess whatever

This theory is definitely interesting, but I couldn't find it believable. But something that did cross my mind was the idea that maybe Dragon was inspired to begin with. There is a possibility that Dragon was at God Valley during the incident, especially given his age begin 55 and the God Valley incident taking place 38 years before the current era. This would make Dragon 17 at the time of the incident. Another alternative to your theory is that Jinny/Ginny was the previous user of the fruit and due to St. Saturn's relation to Bonnie and Kuma he might have somehow obtained Bonnie's fruit.

Another whole in your theory is that the gorosai and the world nobles don’t like people from the surface like what happened with doflamingos dad the dragons did not welcome doflamingo back to maroj so why would they accept shanks as a full blooded celestial dragon?

@10:15 I could have sworn that akainu still wanted to fight but sengoku was giving the orders.

Good video bro, I appreciate seeing people be brave enough to post their theories even others dont agree, i just wanted to say as well though you forgot a crucial part of the topic, how does Shanks stealing the gomu gomu no mi fit into all this?

My out there theory is - the government is fully aware that the Nika fruit has a will of its own and can only be utilized by a certain someone or group to get the one piece - shanks was tasked to set this up and assumed that the chosen one was Rogers son and went to give it to him but fate made luffy eat it. - shanks was shocked but bet his arm on luffy due to luffy having the same dream as roger - shanks has been making moves to ensure luffy reaches his goal - shanks is making moves to claim the one piece as luffy is close to his goal - shanks and the rest of his crew are god knights and will turn on luffy at the end to obtain the one piece for Imu

This is so convoluted 😂 such a waste of time

we saw garling killing mosgard just for stoping charlost in ruining relations with important and well serving fishman island ,so he values celestial dragon wishes over something that big , there is no chance he would give shanks a title of celestial dragon epetialy after working with pirate king who was also a d clan member

Shanks and luffy will both kill imu.

I agree. Hes working for them for the greater good. Possibly beckmans plan.

What if Garland or Imu can control shanks when he’s asleep or drunk etc and he not even know it imu having the power to give him his arm back and erase the scars making it seem like a twin or clone?

you know its not shanks but you want clickbaits

a good video and well-produced theory, but there are too many holes in the theory for me to be persuaded. theres been so many red herrings about shanks and his previous actions/bloodline that i can understand being confused, but narratively there would be too many loose ends conveniently cut off if your idea was how it truly plays out. 1. why were shanks' scars not visible during his God Knight moments? 2. why would the gorosei not be familiar with blackbeard, who was ALREADY A YONKO, if that 907 meeting was truly shanks? 3. why would shanks not know already where loki was if he were coming back to find him once again? in fact, if the most recent chapter were shanks and his God Knight subordinate teleporting to Elbaf, why would shanks be returning at all? There are many other holes to poke, but there is absolutely no way Shanks would be a true celestial dragon, or triple agent for that matter. there are too many sacrifices to live that kind of lifestyle that we've seen already from characters like Mjosgard and the other Donquixotes. I think many of these plot points you argue are caused by Shanks' bloodline are more easily explained by a) Shanks himself being crazy strong (true) and b) Shanks having an identical, evil twin brother. Occam's Razor usually comes out on top with One Piece, as long as there's ample setupe

Shanks can’t disobey the WG because they have Uta

Shanks can’t disobey the WG because they have Uta

there is miscomprehension on Shanks' character in here, its 100% not Shanks

I belive its shanks bc i need more reasons to hate him

bum wasted 15 mins of time

Figarlan D Garling

Shanks telling Ben Beckman it’s time to get the One Piece was him giving his crew something to do while he runs with the God Knights?🤯

I think it's Shanks' brother because of 5 reasons: 1. Why are they looking for Loki? Since Shanks knew where Loki is why would he be asking about his whereabouts. 2. Shanks just left Elbaf. Why would he suddenly come back and use a magic circle when he just left. Shanks also said Luffy isn't ready to see him so why would he contradict himself. 3. Shanks is always with his crew and almost never by himself unless in rare occasions. This woman we would have seen if she was a friend of shanks since we see his crew to a certain degree and no one was being hidden or obscured. So why would he be with an unknown person? 4. Shanks was found in a treasure chest in God Valley, why would Shanks return to serve the WG when his own father literally made him a prize in a tournament and Shanks never mentions his father so it is highly likely they have a strained relationship. 5. I doubt it's a clone I think it will be Shanks' brother that chose the WG and evil while this Shanks chose good and friends. This would make for interesting dynamic between the 2 instead of a boring clone.