Відео

I respect your view, but as Muslims we believe that the universe has a beginning and an end, and that every event that happens happens with God's knowledge. Of course, when you write like this, the question comes to mind that Ibn Sina and Farabi were not Muslims. They were Muslims, but they were wrong in their thinking. They emphasized reason and logic while Ghazali emphasized divine revelation.

@@Horizonsofthemind3437 The fact that everything that happens does so with God's knowledge does not mean that God is the only casual agent. It is not clear and unambiguous in the Qur'an that causality is an illusion; indeed, the Shi'a do believe in secondary causes. And the Mutazilites also. Ghazali wished to emphasize God's power, to his goodness.

Thank you

We have believed in the Day of Resurrection.” (Anbiya, 21/104) I suggest you look at this verse.

Alhamdulilah I am a Muslim. As for artificial intelligence, I don't have the ability to write text. I can't write text, so it is true that I get support from artificial intelligence in writing text. But I do not trust what the AI writes, so I read the text and examine it to the finest detail and then publish it. I research different sources and verify the accuracy of the information. Thank you for your comment.

@@Horizonsofthemind3437 No one asked if you’re a Muslim btw

Islam is not science. Science is based on human observations. Science is fallible, but the rules laid down by Allah are not.

I'm glad you enjoyed it.:))

We believe that the universe has an end as well as a beginning.

What I want to say here is what Ghazali said according to the discourses of Ibn Sina and Farabi.Of course, whatever the Holy Qur'an says, that is Amenna.

Imam Ghazali criticized Ibn Sina's philopsophical views on the eternity of the universe basing on predominantly religious discourse. As a muslim I would say we should't stick to only religous concepts, that's what the main reason for falling behind western countries in sphere of science.We should also shape our scientific knowledges so we can reinvigorate islamic golden age.

​@@SardorBekmuxamedov I disagree with you on some issues. For one thing, the Quran told us centuries ago that the universe is expanding. Modern science has only recently found this out. We just need to shake off the dead soil. We are so used to being lazy.

​@@Horizonsofthemind3437 At some extent I take your point, but that is not the matter I want to explain. I know the facts that holly Coran holds will be gradually exposed through the centuries ahead. But We should be one who will reveal these facts scientifically instead of westerns scholars.

@@SardorBekmuxamedov I totally agree. We always want to be prepared. We need to add something of our own. I believe that if we give more importance to education, these inventions can easily be made by us.

Causality is simply cause and effect. (If you speed, you have an accident. Or if you steal, you become a thief and go to jail.) To me, all of this is a test. The Creator has shown us the right path. He has set rules and regulations. Nothing happens against His will. There are examples of this in all the heavenly books. For example, it has to rain so that the world can live. “He it is Who created the heavens and the earth with truth, and the day He says, 'Be', it comes to pass; His word is truth” (al-An'am, 6/73)

@Horizonsofthemind3437 Did god set the rules? Or since god was always all knowing...the universe and time existed from beginning to end inside his knowledge eternally... God didn't create his knowledge...so did he set the laws or its was the existence of god with which all laws exist as they should...

@@Horizonsofthemind3437 God is the conciousness in which the eternal knowledge of whole existence keeps appearing... The attributes of god arise from his knowledge so we call him all knower(al-aleem)..all wise(al-hakeem)...the absolute time(ad-dahr) God knows what is being me and you... Becs he knows all perspectives.... The material world and time exists in his knowledge in its entirety.... Like your conciousness sees a dream becs of its knowledge...the conciousness or god is real but the world is not real relative to his existence.... Our soul/conciousness becomes conditioned due to body machinary and society when we re born becs of the stories we re fed like our name , what we should run after , whom to hate etc...isnt it nationality and races...but we all re conciousness/souls with different appearing bodies...we come close to reality when we are able differentiate ourselves as being soul(unconditioned conciousness) and not nafs(the character we assume ourselves due to the story of our mind ,body and the world)

It was the Creator who set the laws. The Creator has given us reason and will. He already knows from eternity the decisions we make and will make. He knows that we will choose good and evil. He has shown us the right path through the prophets. He has left it to our will to obey or not. “O mankind, verily We created you from a male and a female (from Adam and Eve). And We have made you into (different) tribes and clans so that you may (easily) get acquainted with each other (and benefit from your different talents and virtues). Verily, the most superior of you in the sight of Allah is the one who is the most advanced in taqwa (avoiding evil and striving for good), not in race or lineage. Verily Allah is All-Knowing, All-Knowing. Surat al-Hujurat, Verse 13” I agree with what you are saying. A newborn child is unconscious. It adopts the truths and ideas of the environment and society in which it lives. And the notion of right - wrong and good - sin comes according to the society they live in.

I don't know anything about this.

It closely aligns with Hume's perspective. However, one issue with this view is that it also assumes God establishes a causal link between "our observations" of a cause and its (non-inherent) effect, as well as our belief in that causal connection (since on this account our observation is what _causes_ our beliefs in inherent causation). Otherwise would our habit of observation nature's cause and effect have an inherent causal effect on our mind. Additionally, it requires (inconsistently) that God's act of causing something must be inherent; otherwise, we encounter a bootstrap problem-namely, that God would need to cause His own causality to function, which would lead to an infinite regress (i.e., God causing the cause that causes the cause, and so on, ad infinitum).

@@andrejuthe There is a Turkish saying “Allah knows”, I don't know how it will translate in English, but sometimes this word saves our faith. Sometimes we don't get too hung up on the “Cause - Effect” relationship (when we can't perceive the event or don't want to think about it) because if Allah did it, He knows something. In my opinion, in every event that happens, either God willed it that way or it happened according to our choices. For example, in the Qur'an (Surah Zâriyât - 47 : We established the sky by Our might and We are expanding it). The Quran informed us about this centuries ago. But modern science has only recently reported that the universe is expanding. Conclusion: the universe is expanding. But why? Who knows. “Dark Energy” according to science.) God knows the unseen. People have interpreted “Causality” either as they can perceive it or as it suits them. That is why there is a lot of misinformation. For example, the ideas of Ibn Sina and Farabi were opposed by al-Ghazali.