Відео

It's an observation with an explanation that has been standardized and refined over time. Like literature or Music with structure and rules to create consistent communication and understanding.

Wow just wow , the wonders of the universe

unfruitful discussions that's it

kkkkkkkkkkk 2:30

The best word to describe math might be an interpretation of our world, not an invention or a simple existence

Math that "we have right now" is an absolute invention, we can actually make our own math that matches the math that the early inventors made as long as you are smart enough you can make one.

The Name of the Asian guy?

So you are saying you invented 2+2=4

The Earth is expanding. More like growing. It has grown 2-3 times it's original size mostly from only 250 million years ago. It's the growing Earth theory and its TRUE. Neil, I hope you read this. You can't prove me wrong. You know it must be true.

i figured out terrence howard. terrence howard is trying to change mathematics by using physics. even though the 2 doesnt correlate by what some scholars say, but they use math to calculate every single thing and to decode the universe. so i dont know hy people say physics and math dont correlate. , maybe thats whats missing. by creating math out of nothing in a moving universe that never stops, make us miscalculate everything we have ever created that we thought was still. our reality sees still objects because we dont see the 4th dimensions. we are looking at the world in a 2D and 3D world that we think is not moving.. howard is trying to see it through a 4D perspective. he has the ability to change everything in his world. terrence literally created saturn from his lynchpin method. and yes he will be seen as crazy for now. just wait til hes able to prove his stuff.

The basics were discovered, over time things were invented in it.

Neil is right, math is an infinite language that describes itself and only itself using patterns. It’s nether discovered nor invented. Its explanation can only be revealed by mathematics itself, no word in our conscious vocabulary can define it. It just describes itself in every equation.

Math : Discovered Numbers : invented

When you think about it, all “invention” is discovery. You’re using something the universe was already capable of

A lot of beans or just a few orders of Taco Bell.

Math is a descriptive subjective system we've invented to describe the phenomenon in our observable universe. It's isn't some sort of divine objective prescriptive system that we discovered. It's our complex answers to complex questions arived at by our logic

Fundamental math concepts are most definetly discovered, more abstract models and number theory and so on just might be invented on top of that. Like the Pythagorean theorem would still exist even if humans never existed, concepts of geometry would still be the same, Pi would still be the same.. etc.

Related question for other commenters: are birds invented or discovered? Every single bird like every living thing on this planet can be said to be directly descended from its parents in many cases parent. Yet there exists an unbroken chain connecting every life on Earth to the same first ancestor. That bird had a mom who was a bird of a particular species however many generations is hard to give an exact answer and can only be given by an approximation. At some point most biologists would likely claim a bird of one species had an ancestor that belonged to a different species. This same reasoning can be applied beyond bird species to every species on Earth in the same manner. We may be comfortable saying a given individual is a bird of a given species but the species is less easily defined. It is real in that it is useful as a way to understand the world and to develop further ideas related to life, the animal kingdom, and birds, but it could be argued the bird was an invention despite agreeing with measurements and experiments. The bird is an abstraction that repeatedly produces results that correspond to reality yet I would argue is a human invention the same way math is. Math is a tool with great agreement and correspondence with nature. On the other hand there can be multiple systems of axioms on which a branch of mathematics may rest. Do all such systems of axioms including even those that may not correspond with reality have their own independent truth even if they are untestable or if they were to fail repeated experimentation? Does math have a standard of truth separate from that of science? Would you say she blinded me with math? 😉

Neil meets his match among fellow superficialists at last😅

Its an Anomaly, Constantly tested in constantly used on different scales.

Yeah the people who figured out a lot of shit would look at nature

Blue lotus wings 🪽

We have a perfectly good model of how a mathematical framework can exist outside of the conscious experience. That's what we have created with computational devices. Just imagine yourselves as beings, made of pixel dust existing inside a matrix. Then you realize your thoughts come from underlying binary code also known as dark matter. You should know a physical architecture or server system can expand from the outside and that expansion is reflected on the inside. That's what dark energy represents, it's not only our container, but it's why the universe is expanding exponentially. The difference is you cannot physically interact with it internally. Through the mind and thoughts we can interact with the mathematical framework. E=MC² hence matter and energy are interchangeable. Light is used as a metaphor for intellect, wisdom and consciousness, without light (electromagnetic radiation), the mathematical framework we use everyday known as computational architectures, wouldn't be accessible to us in such a rich and interactive operating system experience. These architectures show us what mathematical frameworks look like from the outside in. This universe shows us what a mathematical framework looks like, from the inside out.

Math was pre-existing. So math itself, the quantities are not really discovered or invented but Realized. The style in which we choose to code, or write down, the math concepts like a language of symbols are our human invention for the relationship of quantities that we realized. Similar to going outside in the sun and noticing your shadow. You didn't discover your shadow. You didn't invent the shadow. You realized a phenomenon that occurs when certain conditions are met, a phenomenon that was pre-existing.

I have learned a lot of wisdom from old tales and religious quotes with a deep meaning my favourite was this, and I write it in hungarian because it sounds better: "Az ember tudatlannak születik, nem ostobának, ostobává az oktatás teszi". This sums up the operation we have here very well. The other thing I have learned when I went down alone to an illegal underground party was "sacred geometry". So, those people who exist behind the door says "do not enter" is actually people who possess wisdom that is sacred. You guys are doing media here. You not gonna know the world behind closed doors. You shouldn't.

It’s obviously a discovention

Math is like time and space !!! Without time and space there is no math !! Time and space the closer something is less time is needed if touching you no time needed at all or math coz nothing to work out !!! To me it's obvious time and space are the same thing !! Playing football you learn to run into the space so you have more time on the ball !!!!!!

Math is the substrate from which the universe springs forth.

Did the earth blow up like a balloon? I see it on the internet all the time.

Why do people act like neil is a genius ? Hes a scientist in 1 field not every field.

Dude gave his son an ultimatum between math and astrophysics LOL

Why is the big bang theory stuffed down our throat amwe have other theories which I accept are not perfect bit neither is the big bang

Think about how silly it would be to say Isaac Newton invented gravity... It was always there at a very specific reliable value making it a discovery. I believe math also is a discovery in the same way that 4 bananas plus 4 bananas always equaled 8 bananas. We just discovered a way to explain it. To invent math means you could assign any value to anything you want and call it true despite the entire universe laughing at you.

GREEKS INVENTED MATH 💪🏼🇬🇷🇨🇾

what about programming language isn't it completely arbitrary?

We invented the kickoff version of it to account for things like sheep but all of the laws existed beforehand, explorations of it's possibilities led to discoveries, not inventions of universal laws.

Math is definitely a discovery. It exists, whether we knew about it or not.

What's the name of the first man who spoke? For research purposes only.

"In order to get ahold of the wiggly world you've gotta put a net over it" - And so, the the art of calculus was born. Now we can number the holes of the net, so many so holes up, so many so holes across, and now we can measure, calculate, and talk about the wiggly world in regards to the net. The funniest part of all is that as human beings we tend to try and straighten out the wiggly world and build in straight lines with right angles, but each and every one of us is wiggly as all get out. The wiggliest wiggle of them all tries to straighten out a wiggly world. Lol This is Alan Watts by the way. One of his philosophical lectures on calculus and the universe. It is wonderful.

I like that Asian guy lol. I know who Neil is already and have much respect for him but that discovention joke was freaking hilarious!

What about the theory of the Big Bounce in which universes emerge from Black Holes? I wonder how they don't come to mention that

The way Neil didn’t even want to comment on the discovention, so he just kept on talking but was interrupted by singing instead so he tried to talk through that and couldn’t… he paused for one second and then just continued his sentence as if nothing had happened 😂😂😂

Is this a podcast? Where can I find it??? Neil Degrase Tyson please start your own podcast and talk about space !!!!

Big bong

Invention. This is really not a hard question.

Neil Degrasse is wrong here. The universe does not "follow" rules. This is actually hard for som people to grasp. Grasp it - don´t Degrasse it.

Everything is discovered nothing is invented

I'd like to hear these guys discuss Roger Penrose's idea of an endlessly repeating universe of multiple big bangs... I thought the evidence had disproved the idea of a Big Crunch?!?

Math is a pidgin between the language of the universe and the language of our minds.

First off you fail to understand something the ( observable) universe not the WHOLE universe totally different 😑it’s ether the WHOLE universe is finite or not 😐and no matter how far you look the speed of light will always be finite 😑so no matter how far away we see our range will be limited and if the observable universe is the whole universe then we sure live in a very small universe 😐